Hadoop: Primitive Array Clustering

Hadoop implementation of Canopy Clustering using Levenshtein distance algorithm and other non-mathematical distance measures (such as Jaccard coefficient).

Difference with Mahout

One of the major limitation of Mahout is that the clustering algorithms (K-Means or Canopy clustering) use a mathematical approach in order to compute Clusters’ centers. Each time a new point is added to a cluster, Mahout framework recomputes cluster’s center as an average of data points.

NewCenter[i] = Sum(Vectors)[i] / observations

As a result, only purely mathematical DistanceMeasure can be used. But…

  • What if your data set is composed of non-mathematical data points ?
  • What if an average of points does not make any sense for your business ?
  • Or simply what if you wish to use a non (or less) mathematical distance measure ?


I had to create canopies for sequences of IDs (Integer). Let’s take the following example with 2 vectors V1 and V2.

V1={0:123, 1:23, 2:55, 3:141, 4:22}
V2={0:23, 1:55, 2:141, 3:22}

These vectors are totally different using most of standard Mathematical measures Mahout provides (e.g. Euclidean). I can still change the way my vectors are created, but none of the solution I tried were considering my arrays as a sequence of IDs and furthermore a sequence of IDs where the order matters. Levensthein metric (that is usually used for fuzzy string matching) is a perfect match as it compares sequences of IDs and not only IDs as numbers.

I had to create a new set of DistanceMeasure taking arrays as Input parameters.
Besides, assuming both of them belongs to a same cluster, does a new cluster’s center V’ (made as an average of points from V1 and V2) makes sense for sequence analysis ?

V'={0:(23+123)/2, 1:(55+23)/2, 2:(141+55)/2, 3:(22+141)/2, 4:(0+22)/1}

I had to find a way to override Mahout cluster’s center computation. Instead of computing an average of data points, I find the point Pi that minimizes the distance across all cluster’s data points.
Pseudo code:

Point min_point = Pi
float min_dist = Infinity
For each point Pi
  For each point Pj
    Compute distance Pi->Pj
    Update min_point, min_dist if distance < min_dist

Center = minimum

Distance Measures

Supported distance measures are

  • com.aamend.hadoop.clustering.distance.LevenshteinDistance measure
  • com.aamend.hadoop.clustering.distance.TanimotoDistance measure
  • Any Measure implementing com.aamend.hadoop.clustering.distance.DistanceMeasure

Primitive Arrays

Only Integer.class is supported on Version 1.0. It is planned however to support any of the Java primitive arrays (boolean[], char[], int[], double[], long[], float[]). I invite you to actively contribute to this project.


Even though the project has been directly inspired by Mahout canopy clustering, it does not depend on any of Mahout libraries. Instead of using Mahout Vector, I use arrays of Integer, and instead of Mahout VectorWritable, I use Hadoop ArrayPrimitiveWritable. Simply add the maven dependency to your project. Releases versions should be available on Maven Central (synched from Sonatype). Even though this project (actively depends on Hadoop libraries) has been built around Hadoop CDH4 distribution, this can be easily overridden on client side by using maven “exclusion” tag in order to use any of the Hadoop versions / distributions.

        <!-- Should you need to override / exclude hadoop deps. -->


Create canopies

Use buildClusters static method from com.aamend.hadoop.clustering.job.CanopyDriver class

* @param conf the Hadoop Configuration
* @param input the Path containing input PrimitiveArraysWritable
* @param output the final Path where clusters / data will be written to
* @param reducers the number of reducers to use (at least 1)
* @param measure the DistanceMeasure
* @param t1 the float CLUSTER_T1 distance metric
* @param t2 the float CLUSTER_T2 distance metric
* @param cf the minimum observations per cluster
* @return the number of created canopies
public static long buildClusters(
    Configuration conf, Path input,
    Path output, int reducers,
    DistanceMeasure measure,
    float t1, float t2, long cf){

This will build Canopies using several Map-Reduce jobs (at least 2, driven by the initial number of reducers). Firstly, because we need to keep track of each observed point per clusters in order to minimize intra-distance of data points (obviously cannot fit in memory), Secondly because the measure used here might be fairly inneficient using a single Map job (Levenshtein complexitiy is O(n*m)). In order to allow a smooth run without any hot spot, at each iteration, the number of reducers is 2 times smaller (until reached 1) while {T1,T2} parameters gets slightly larger (starts with half of the required size). Clustering algorithm is defined according to the supplied DistanceMeasure (can be a custom measure implementing DistanceMeasure assuming it is available on Hadoop classpath).

The input data should be a sequenceFile format using any key class (implementing WritableComparable interface) and value should be ArrayPrimitiveWritable (serializing integer array).

The output will be a sequenceFile format using Cluster Id as key (IntWritable) and com.aamend.hadoop.clustering.clusterCanopyWritable as value.

Cluster input data

Once canopies are created, use static clusterData method from com.aamend.hadoop.clustering.job.CanopyDriver class

* @param conf the Configuration
* @param inputData the Path containing input arrays
* @param dataPath the final Path where data will be written to
* @param clusterPath the path where clusters have been written
* @param measure the DistanceMeasure
* @param minSimilarity the minimum similarity to cluster data
* @param reducers the number of reducers to use (at least 1)
public static void clusterData(
    Configuration conf, Path inputData,
    Path dataPath, Path clusterPath,
    DistanceMeasure measure,
    float minSimilarity, int reducers){

This will retrieve the most probable clusters any point should belongs to. If not 100% identical to cluster’s center, we cluster data if similarity is greater than X% (minSimilarity). Canopies (created at previous steps) are added to Distributed cache.

The output will be a sequenceFile format using Cluster Id as key (IntWritable) and ObjectWritable as value (object pointing to your initial WritableComparable key so that you can keep track of which point belongs to which cluster)



Source code is available on https://github.com/aamend/hadoop-primitive-clustering


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s